Sunset Bay Vacation Rentals

12889 A & B Iola Drive - Corner of Shady Across from the Beach Club. Two cottages in the heart of the action. 10 ft. from beach, beautiful lake views, sunsets and sandy beaches. Fully furnished, amenities include gas grill. Guests bring linens and all consumables.

Cottage A: 3 bedroom $995 a week plus security - 2 double beds, 1 queen size bed, 2 couches. 8 person max.

Cottage B: 2 bedroom $775 a week plus security - 1 double bed, 1 queen size bed, 1 pullout couch. 6 person max.

Available May thru September. Contact us for winter rates. Spring and Fall weekends available (remember opening and closing parties). E-Mail for photos.

Contact MJ at 716-308-7418

Great Location in the Center of Everything Going On! Two Cottages located four houses down from the Cabana Sam's & Deli. Fully furnished, bring linens and toiletries. Very nice, very clean cottages. 20 years rental experience with an excellent reputation.

3-Bedroom: 1004 Newton Road, $950 a week plus security - (Sat.-Sat.) Available starting in June. $550 for monthly winter rates plus utilites. Available 8/27-9/5.

2-Bedroom: 1015 South Shore Drive, $850 a week plus security - (Sat.-Sat.) $400 for monthy winter rate plus utilities. Available 8/20-8/27, 8/27-9/5.

Cottages are available all year round. Winter rentals starting right after labor day by the month or weekends are available. E-Mail us with your name and address to be put on our mailing list.

Contact: Robin at 674-3321 or 310-5986

12878 Iola Drive Across from the Beach Club and Beach! Renovated large 2 Bath/4 Bedroom house with laundry and central A/C. Comes fully furnished and includes gas grill, TV, CD player, DVD player, 20 case beer/pop cooler, and a nice back yard. 10 person max occupancy (family atmosphere a necessity). $1,500 per week ($600 down deposit).

Rentals available starting June 1st, all the luxuries of home with an at the beach atmosphere

Contact Sam at 716-694-4900

12782 Iola Drive. Quaint smaller fully furnished cottage with only a 4 minute walk to the beach! 3 bedroom, 1 bathroom, kitchen, sleeps 6 to 8 comfortably. Plenty of room for parking. Fully furnished with AC, Microwave, coffee pot, stove, basic cable TV & grill provided. Just bring your own linen and toiletries. Available for the summer from Sunday to Sunday. $1000 per week + $500 security. Rentals available starting June 1st.

Contact Sam at 716-694-4900

Daily Double Duplex. 954 Charles Street. Family Reunion? Several families vacationing together? We have the perfect place for you! This huge home is really a side-by-side double and features a large fenced yard and covered deck with 6 Bedrooms and 3 Baths. ​

The "A" side has a large kitchen, new half-bath downstairs, and a nice size living room on the 1st floor. 2nd floor has 3 bedrooms, one with 3 twin beds, one with a queen, and the third with a double, along with a full upstairs bath.

The "B" side has a new kitchen and new full bath downstairs across from a bedroom with queen bed. This bedroom is perfect for an elderly parent or someone who wants a quiet room separated from the upstairs bedrooms. Upstairs you will find one bedroom with 3 single beds and another with 2 doubles.

Outside is a covered back porch, 40 feet in length with deck furniture, making it a favorite with vacationers. The large fenced back yard is perfect for baby pools and family activities and yard games. The yard also includes a large fire pit and parking for 9 cars. Like all of our cottages, it is clean, fully furnished and includes televisions, pots/pans, kitchen tools and dishes, a gas grill and passes for the Sunset Bay Beach (4 minute walk). ​Linens and personal items not included.

Max. Occupancy: Side A - 9, Side B - 9. Rents Saturday to Saturday. $850 / $950 per side. Different pricing available for off season.

Contact Joan at 716-934-3835

The Irish Dreamer. 1012 Newton Street. A quaint three bedroom, one bath cottage located directly across the street from Cabana Sam's restaurant. Enjoy your sandy location on your outside deck with an outdoor table and chairs perfect for getting sun and outdoor eating. Includes a fire pit for windless nights. The first bedroom has a queen size bed, the other rooms include built-in single captains beds. The cottage has a nice living room with basic cable television, a cozy updated kitchen with new appliances, and a dishwasher. It is clean, fully furnished and includes pots/pans, kitchen tools & dishes, a gas grill and passes for the Sunset Bay Beach. Linens and personal items not included. There is parking on the Newton Street side for 3 cars.

Max. occupancy of 5. Rents Saturday to Saturday. $850 / $950 in season. Different pricing available for off season

Contact Joan at 716-934-3835

Kate's Place. 1010 Newton Street. Across from the beach with large beach yard. 2 bedrooms, one with a pillow top queen and one with 2 double beds. Lovely knotty pine large living room with 30in. wall mount TV, white leather furniture and sky lights. All ceramic kitchen with dishwasher. Nice eating area and a new bath with shower and tub. Outside is a large deck with tables and chairs, parking for 4-5 cars and the beach and Cabana Sam’s are just steps away. Gas grill and fire pit. Dishes, silverware, pots and pans, large variety of cooking utensils, microwave, coffeepot, toaster, cleaning products and passes for the Sunset Bay Beach. Fully furnished. Linens and personal items not included.

Max. Occupancy of 7. Rents Saturday to Saturday. $850 / $1000 in season. Different pricing available for off season.

Contact Joan at 716-934-3835

Kristy Lynn Inn. 1027 Southshore. A cozy cottage located directly across from the beach with an outside deck facing the beach perfect for tanning. Two bedrooms, one with a double bed and one with bunk beds, a double bottom bunk and a single on top. New ceramic bathroom with tankless hot water. The living room has a sliding glass door overlooking the deck, a couch, two chairs, a 30 in. wall mounted television with basic cable. A cute kitchen sits off the living room equipped with dishes, silverware, pots and pans, a large variety of cooking utensils, coffee pot and toaster and passes for the Sunset Bay Beach. Fully furnished. Linens and personal items not included. Parking for 3 cars.

Max. occupancy of 6. Rents Saturday to Saturday. $850 / $950 in season. Different pricing available for off season.

Contact Joan at 716-934-3835

Kimby's Cottage. 1006 Newton Road. Fully furnished cozy cottage located directly across from the beach. It has an outside deck perfect for tanning or family dinner. Two bedrooms, 1one with a double bed and one with 2 single beds. Bathroom with shower and vanity. Kitchen is equipped with dishes, silverware, pots and pans, large variety of cooking utensils, coffee pot and toaster. Includes television, a gas grill, patio furniture and passes for the Sunset Bay Beach. Linens and personal items not included. Parking for 3 cars.

Max. Occupancy of 5. Rents Saturday to Saturday. $850 / $950 in season. Different pricing available for off season.

Contact Joan at 716-934-3835

Interested in listing your rental property here? Take advantage of this high traffic targeted marketing resource and say goodbye to occasional vacancies at your property!

Simply email your information (address, availability, cost, number of bedrooms, interesting features, etc., as well as your phone number and email address) using the link below to us. You may also send us up to 9 photos for inclusion with the listing. Photos should be saved at 72dpi for easy email transfer. Then click on the "Purchase a Listing" link below to complete your transaction. Type the address of your rental property in the message box. One address per listing. Listing order is based upon a "first come, first served" basis. Rental listings updates are preformed Monday thru Friday during business hours.

Listings are $75 per rental property per year.

This directory is provided as a service and only facilitates the exchange of information between property owners and potential renters.

Sunset Bay Beach Club, Cabana Sam's, Keller Graphics and any of their affiliates do not verify either the information regarding the properties advertised or the identity of the contact person and do not assume responsibility or guarantee the accuracy of the information contained on the individual listings.

Sunset Bay Beach Club, Cabana Sam's, Keller Graphics and any of their affiliates cannot be held responsible for any disputes that may arise between property owners and renters.

Renters are responsible for conducting their own investigation regarding any and all claims made by prospective renters or cottage owners. Renters assume all liability for use of any information they find in this listings directory.

Report Abuse

If you feel that this video content violates the Adobe Terms of Use, you may report this content by filling out this quick form.

To report a Copyright Violation, please follow Section 17 in the Terms of Use.