Are we the enemy? by Thomas Birmingham

In 1787, the United States was in a state of self-discovery. As the founding fathers drafted radical new ideas about their young democracy, a need to prevent the government from becoming too powerful remained at the forefront of their minds. And it was in January of that year Thomas Jefferson famously wrote to a friend, “Were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers, or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter.”

Nine months later, the Bill of Rights would become law, as would the phrase ‘Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of the press.” Now, over 200 years after these words were written, this free press, this essential safeguard against the powerful, this pillar of democracy, is under attack.

In February of 2017 President Donald Trump made the bold claim on Twitter that the “news media is the enemy of the American people.” This proclamation combined with weaponizing phrases like “fake news” to use on some of the nation’s most respected news outlets has solidified Trump as the news media’s primary antagonist. His rhetoric has earned a large following in the public, with 29 percent of Americans believing that the news media is, in fact, their enemy, according to The Boston Globe. That these American citizens are, somehow, un-American.

These dangerous messages come amidst major figures in the Trump administration attempting to convince the country that journalists – other than those in blatant, unflinching support of Trump – are incapable of telling the truth. Trump’s senior advisor Kellyanne Conway coined the term “alternative facts” less than two months after Trump’s inauguration, and Trump lawyer Rudy Giuliani recently declared on national TV that ‘truth isn’t truth.’ For months, this administration has attempted to muddle the media’s abilities to keep the public informed which are essential to even the most basic democracy. In the eyes of his supporters, Trump has made it so that he can never tell a lie.

What is so alarming about Trump’s apparent disdain for journalists is that he seems to be the first president in American history to lack a basic respect for the fourth estate and the rights of the press guaranteed in the First Amendment. At an event Trump held in July, he informed his audience that, “what you’re seeing and what you’re reading is not what’s happening.” Trump has delivered such lines, lines which many high school English students will say could have been taken straight from the pages of George Orwell’s 1984, with incredible disregard for the potential future implications of branding a free press as an enemy of freedom.

Trump’s anti-media bombardment has taken root within his own party. The Boston Globe reported that nearly half of Republicans believe the free press is the enemy of the American people, and almost a quarter want to give Trump the power to shut down news outlets like CNN and The New York Times. He has managed to draw the issue of freedom of the press along party lines. But the free press must never be minimized to partisanship, because a free press, after all, is synonymous with the ideals of democracy. Democracy doesn’t work without free press, and a free press cannot work if the citizens it is meant to inform do not trust its legitimacy.

But Trump has not only managed to diminish the value of the institution of journalism as a whole, but he has also stomped heedlessly on the memory of so many of the American heroes in this profession.

TKC staffers work to produce content for the newsmagazine and website

When he threatened to ban papers like the Washington Post and the New York Times from the White House Press Corp, he failed to honor the work of Bob Woodward and Carl Bernstein in uncovering the Watergate scandal.

When he carelessly calls an entire profession fake and biased, he forgets that Benjamin Franklin, one of our nation’s most beloved historical figures, owned and operated his own paper in Philadelphia.

When he called journalists ‘bad people’ at a rally one week after five of them were mercilessly gunned down this year in Annapolis, Maryland, he spits on the legacy of reporters like Ernie Pyle, who was killed while covering American troops during World War II, as well as the brave journalists who are killed across the globe every year in places where simply reporting the news accurately is punishable by death.

Are these people, these founding fathers, these war heroes, these brave men and women, really the enemy of the American people? Are they really my enemy? Are they yours?

By implicating in the entire journalism profession in his long list of enemies, he has also directed his attacks at the over 90 staffers of The Kirkwood Call. We, who take pride in being able to provide students with the news of the Kirkwood community, have been unfairly called out. We, who spend hours making sure we check every fact and get every story right, have been attacked by our own president. We, whose only goal is to serve our readers, have been stamped with a label we don’t deserve.

Are we your enemy?

On a basic level, our president’s tirades are not without merit. There has been a growing epidemic of fake articles, misleading headlines and journalists who value being first over being right. And of course, there are some news outlets that are politically motivated to oppose Trump, just as there are outlets politically motivated to support him. But Trump has taken this problem and used it to bully, defame and shame anyone who believes in getting the truth of our society out to the public. As if there was something inherently wrong about telling the truth.

But we are not publishing this article for Trump. He has demonstrated time and time again that he is unlikely to ever change his mind about us. We are publishing this article for you. The people.

To show you that having the desire to hold the powerful accountable does not make you a liar. To demonstrate that having a commitment to telling the truth does not make you un-American. To convince you that being a journalist, no matter what age, does not make you the enemy of your fellow citizens.

And just as a democracy needs a free press, the press needs the public’s involvement and support. So after reading this, we encourage you to step away from the shouting, finger-pointing and fear-mongering and take a moment to look at the world around you. Be curious. Be skeptical. Question those with authority. Be involved.

This way, rather than being divided as enemies, we can unite in our goal to uphold the truth, our democracy and most importantly, our freedom.

Report Abuse

If you feel that this video content violates the Adobe Terms of Use, you may report this content by filling out this quick form.

To report a Copyright Violation, please follow Section 17 in the Terms of Use.