The true Birthplace of Buddha By Sarah Sun

Buddha, Siddhartha Gautama, grew up in the palace of Kapilvastu. Unfortunately, right now no one is sure where Kapilvastu is located. Some archeologists claim that it is in Piprahwa, India while many others claim that it is in fact located in Tilaurakot, Nepal. The reason why this is such a controversial topic is because there has never been any detailed and comprehensive records of it's whereabouts. It is crucially important to figure out exactly where it is located because it will become an important pilgrimage and tourism site for both Buddhists and other people, including Americans.

Siddhartha Gautama was born around 623 B.C. He grew up in his father's luxurious palace in the city of Kapilvastu. He was forbidden by his father to leave the palace for the first 29 years of his life, thus he was never exposed the sufferings of life. As soon as he left the palace he saw the four sights, which prompt him to immediately leave his luxurious life behind and become an ascetic in order to find the end of human suffering.

It has already been 2,500 years since the life of Buddha and since then there has been lots of confusion and no clear records on this matter. The only written account we have of where Kapilvastu is is from Huen Tsian, a Chinese scholar who travelled to India in search of Buddhism during the 6th century AD. The search for Kapilvastu began during the mid-19th century AD, when they finally managed to translate Huen Tsian's recount.

"Monasteries and stupas are built over the ruins of the royal precincts.”

As you can tell the description is pretty vague so it's very hard to be sure exactly where it is.

“Engulfed in complete darkness, the scholars made a beginning in the direction of locating Kapilavastu like a wild-goose chase,” K. M. Srivastava

History of Piprahwa

January 1898, William C Peppe made a shocking discovery of a stupa buried under his estate in Piprahwa, India. In the 1970s, Srivastava, an archaeologist excavated the site again. He found an additional stupa with 4 monasteries surrounding it on either sides. Within the stupa, a casket containing terra-cotta seals and other relics was uncovered. On one such relic “sukiti bhatinam sabhaginikanam sa puta dalanam iyam salila nidhane buddha bhagvate sakiyanam” was inscribed in Brahmi. It translates to- brothers, sister, kinsmen and successors hereby bury the relics of Buddha. All of this led some people to firmly believe this is the secret site of Kapilvastu, since there are monasteries and stupas just like in Huen Tsian’s recount.

Western Monastery

There was only one problem, there's absolutely no evidence of a palace structure at Piprahwa at any point in history. This proved to be quite a significant problem because Buddha most definitely lived in a palace. However the Indian archeologists have found an explanation- right next door to Piprahwa is the site of Ganwaria which coincidently contained a palace structure. Perhaps these two sites were both part of Kapilvastu back in the past before getting labeled as two separate sites in modern day India.

History of Tilaurakot

Tilaurakot is close to Lumbini- a very important Buddhist pilgrimage site. An Ashoka pillar was found at Lumbini, the inscription confirms that is the birth place of the Buddha. Asoka pillars were built by Emperor Ashoka in 249 B.C. to promote the spread of Buddhism after he became a Buddhist. This led archeologists to think the palace is very close by.

Ashoka pillar

Debala Mitra led an unsuccessful expedition in the 1960s at Tilaurakot, the team soon gave up when they came across a brick structure that was built hundreds of years after Buddha would have lived there. Having said that, recently another team supported by Unesco went back to the site, cut through the brick structure to reveal an original clay palace wall within that matched the time period. The evidence of Kapilvastu was further proved by cylindrical depressions found underneath the ground indicating the places where timber fence posts use to stand. Those were dated to at least 2,800 years ago, a time when Buddha would have been living in the palace. Other parts of an ancient city-houses, roads, walls and wells were also uncovered.

Tilaurakot site

Tilaurakot is the official birth place of the buddha verified by the UNESCO World Heritage Center.

The archaeologist’s team comprised mainly of 10 professors from Stirling University and Durham University of the United Kingdom, two Unesco consultants, five experts from the DoA and four from the Lumbini Development Trust.

There are a few reasons why both India and Nepal are so desperate to prove Kapilvastu is in their country. Firstly For a long times Buddhism has had a weak power in the world, making it significantly easier for an Asian countries to take control over it. Now Nepal has allied itself to China, they are competing against India to have the biggest claim to Buddhism. Whoever has the claim will hook in thousands of people spending money each year.

Relics displayed in the Piprahwa museum.

Kapilvastu will be a huge attraction for religious pilgrims and tourists alike. Currently India’s prize attraction is Bodh Gaya, where Buddha gained enlightenment, but if Kapilvastu is confirmed to be at Piprahwa it will bring in thousands of tourists each year which will be greatly beneficial to the economy. A museum has already been opened near the site to display all the evidences found, this will compel tourists to spend money there.The same thing applies in Nepal, if Kapilvastu is confirmed to be at Tilaurakot, Nepal's economy would benefit. Nepal has begun to make a $54 million upgrade to the airport of Lumbini. The upgraded airport will be able to accommodate 760,000 passengers a year, these passengers will largely be made up by tourists who will spend money.

Plus Kapilvastu is a very sacred site for Buddhists, it carries the legacy of Buddhism. The place where Siddhartha Gautama left in order to pursue the end of suffering.

  • http://www.buddhistedu.org/en/index.php/dhamma-class/14-class-lessons/101-the-life-of-siddhartha-gautama- (images 1&2 )
  • www.r4e.org/silkroad/hsuan_tsang.htm
  • http://www.piprahwamuseum.com/
  • http://cmualumniusa.org/relicbk.htm
  • http://www.goldengateholidays.com/?tours=lumbini-tour-packages
  • http://www.hotelmirageinn.com/content/tilaurakot
  • http://www.travelomy.com/ashoka-pillar-of-lumbini-photos-videos
  • http://kathmandupost.ekantipur.com/news/2016-03-11/ancient-infrastructure-found-in-tilaurakot-dig.html
  • https://buddhistartnews.wordpress.com/2013/01/08/the-kapilavastu-controversy-part-iv/

Made with Adobe Slate

Make your words and images move.

Get Slate

Report Abuse

If you feel that this video content violates the Adobe Terms of Use, you may report this content by filling out this quick form.

To report a Copyright Violation, please follow Section 17 in the Terms of Use.