COMS 225 WEEK 5

Announcements

  • Thought Essay #1 graded
  • No more quizzes- Midterm in two weeks

Agenda

  • Identify types of arguments
  • Identify components of Toulmin Model
  • Identify refutation process
  • SPAR Debate implementing arguments constructed via Toulmin Model & preparing a brief

Types of Arguments

TOULMIN MODEL

  • Claim
  • Grounds
  • Warrant
  • Backing
  • Modality
  • Rebuttal

CLAIM

  • A statement you are asking the other person to accept.
  • Either change of action or change of thought.
  • What’s the point of your argument?
  • Ex: You should get a hearing aid

GROUNDS

  • The support for your claim
  • examples, facts, statistics, testimonies
  • Ex. Over 70% of people over the age of 65 years old have hearing difficulty

WARRANT

  • The inferential leap that connects the grounds to claim
  • Inferential leap: implicit/unspoken reasoning
  • Ex. A hearing aid helps most people hear better
  • Exercise #1:
  • Claim: My neighbors car is on fire
  • Grounds: There is smoke coming from my neighbors car
  • What is the warrant?

FINDING GROUNDS

What counts as credible sources?

.com, .edu, .gov

SPAR DEBATES - PREP PART 1

  • Resolution: Animal testing should be banned in the U.S.
  • Team 1 & 2 = AFF
  • Team 3 & 4 = NEG
  • Directions:
  • In your teams, fill out the worksheet by developing at least two arguments using the Toulmin model for your side
  • Up to 15min to do research and prepare as a team

Refuting Arguments

What is refutation?

Refutation Process

1. Listen carefully

2. Critically evaluate the arguments

  • Determine what the advocate is arguing
  • Evaluate the reasoning and/or grounds they use

3. Formulate a response

  • Be strategic- what is the arguer’s weakest point?
  • Consider the situation and audience
  • Form a brief (series of arguments and supporting evidence for a specific point of clash)
  • Anticipate what the opponent might argue (consider stock issues)

4. Present the response

  • Tell the audience what point you are refuting
  • Support your refutation- how can you support your claim?
  • We try to do this all the time - SPAR debates
  • Two types of ways to refute - declarative and questioning

Example:

  • (Signaling) My opponent argued that the death penalty deters crime.
  • (State) In fact, the death penalty increases crime.
  • (Support) According to a nationwide study conducted by Professor Wiggins in 2002, violent crime has actually increased in states with the death penalty while crime has decreased in states without the death penalty.
  • (Importance) If this study is true, and the methodology is certainly sound, then the central justification for why they say we need the death penalty has no merit.

SPAR DEBATE - PREP PART 2

  • Resolution: Animal testing should be banned in the U.S.
  • Team 1 & 2(AFF)
  • Team 3 & 4 (NEG)
  • In the same team as earlier, anticipate two arguments that the other team might make and prepare responses
  • In the end, your team should have two arguments AND two counterarguments ready for the debate
  • Up to 15min prep time

SPAR DEBATE

Resolution: Animal testing should be banned in the U.S.

Team 1&2 (AFF) vs 3&4 (NEG)

  • Team 1 get together w/ Team 2
  • Team 3 get together w/ Team 4
  • Game plan together, share args, decide who is speaking when
  • AFF think about plan and definitions
  • PREP time 5min

Made with Adobe Slate

Make your words and images move.

Get Slate

Report Abuse

If you feel that this video content violates the Adobe Terms of Use, you may report this content by filling out this quick form.

To report a Copyright Violation, please follow Section 17 in the Terms of Use.