Comparing and Contrasting Short Stories

The Telltale Heart and Lady and the Tiger

In the Telltale Heart the story begins with the Narrator expressing his nervousness, which I linked to the likelihood of previous internal debate. Just like the Princess in the Lady and the Tiger the Narrator has to decide whether or not someone will die. Both characters were conflicted in their decisions and they were swayed one way or another by intense internal conflict. However the Telltale Heart seems to be based in a setting closer to our time with elements of electricity and police included, whereas the Lady and the Tiger is clearly based in a ancient Bronze Age sort of city with semi barbaric crime and punishments. The Telltale Heart is focused entirely around the murder of the old man and the subsequent hallucinations and confessions, while the Lady or the Tiger is more focused on the debate over whether or not someone would die and less on the death of someone. In the Telltale Heart the Narrator was the murderer but inversely in the Lady or the Tiger the Princess did not commit murder but simply witnessed the act of a tiger. (If indeed he died at all) . Though they both circumvented the workings of the mind I don't really think they were particularly similar.

As previously described The Lady and the Tiger is essentially the set up for the Princess's intense conflict between her love and hate, morals and barbaric disposition. Flowers for Algernon entails the exploits of the mentally challenged Charlie Gordon, particularly his surgery to triple his intelligence. Both are focused on the mind, and the conflict thereof.

However the stories are narrated quite differently, The Lady and the Tiger from the perspective of an all knowing author, and Flowers for Algernon from the journal entries of Charlie. The stories also differ in time period, one set in a barbaric Bronze Age the other in modern day. They also have different themes, ( though both are about mind) , The Lady and the Tiger about the polar opposites of human passion, and Flowers for Algernon about the gain and subsequent loss of thought capability.

The Lady and the Tiger begins with a description of the setting and lead up to the princess's moral dilemma, and concludes with the posing of the title question to the reader. Flowers for Algernon begins with a showcase of Charlie's current grammar and spelling skills, which continue to climb throughout the course of the book. Despite the differences in layout, the decisions the readers were compelled to make were surprisingly similar. They both decided to gain knowledge, ( the princess finding out what was behind each door, and Charlie agreeing to surgery) and each had to decide what to do with the knowledge once gained.

The Telltale Heart and Flowers for Algernon exist in a possibly similar time frame, the Telltale Heart avoiding specification of time period, and Flowers for Algernon existing in a clearly modern, or possibly even futuristic world. Though not a striking similarity it sets the background for some of the similar elements, such as the character's shared desire to enact change because someone looks at them funny. (Quite a stretch I know but I'm having difficulty finding similarities) . The biggest similarity is the way in which they are both narrated each described from the main characters view with only guesses at others thoughts.

There is however a much larger pile of differences to draw on, such as the characters levels of patience, intelligence, and motives, which vary to the extreme throughout the stories. The Narrator of the Telltale Heart is quite patient at least until the moment of action comes, while Charlie is seemingly the reverse, rushing through the Rorschach and races against Algernon, until the after effects of surgery sink in. The characters begin at inverse poles of intelligence, with the Narrator at the height of strategy and planning, and Charlie refusing to pretend there are images in ink blots. As each book progresses however, thought levels change, the Narrator progressively becoming more and more insane, and Charlie beginning his enormous climb and subsequent decline of intelligence. The books also have very different themes, one relying on bloody thrills, and the consequences of murder, the other on the absoluteness of intellectual prowess.

Altogether, the books take various approaches to the workings of the human mind, while conveying different themes. The Lady and the Tiger focusing on the conflict of lust, hate, jealousy and passion, against the workings of love and affection. The Telltale Heart touching on insanity and the workings of a mind gone wrong, particularly the consequences of crimes to such a tainted mind. Flowers for Algernon circumventing the topic of someone's intellectual standing in the world versus a desire to learn, and whether or not you should do so. Though each book alights upon a different tone, they each speak their opinion on human conflict and decisions. ( Which is true for most books, as I said, I'm a little stretched) .


Created with images by jarmoluk - "library book britannica"

Report Abuse

If you feel that this video content violates the Adobe Terms of Use, you may report this content by filling out this quick form.

To report a Copyright Violation, please follow Section 17 in the Terms of Use.