The College of New Jersey has featured 40 individual NCAA Champions, 10 NCAA relay champions, and an ITA National Champion over its illustrious history.
WOMEN'S SWIMMING AND DIVING
- 1997 - Diane Maise - 1 Meter Diving
- 2008 - Ava Kiss - 100 Butterfly
- 2011 - Danica Roskos - 1 Meter Diving
- 2011 - Danica Roskos - 3 Meter Diving
- 2012 - Danica Roskos - 1 Meter Diving
- 2013 - Danica Roskos - 1 Meter Diving
MEN'S SWIMMING & DIVING
- 1994 - Matt Stoll - 200 Breaststroke
- 2006 - Steve Swenson - 100 Breaststroke
- 2014 - Joe Dunn, Brett Pedersen, Stephen Tarnowski, and Stephen Gibson - 200 Free Relay
- 2014 - Joe Dunn, Brett Pedersen, Stephen Tarnowski, and Stephen Gibson - 400 Free Relay
- 2015 - Joe Dunn, Brett Pedersen, Scott Vitabile, and Brian Perez - 400 Free Relay
- 2015 - Ryan Gajdzisz, Scott Vitabile, Brett Pedersen, and Jason Ivins - 800 Free Relay
- 2023 - James McChesney - 200 Free
WRESTLING
- 1978 - Mike Rossetti - 126 pounds
- 1979 - Mike Rossetti - 126 pounds
- 1981 - Mike Jacoutot - 126 pounds
- 1981 - Kevin Walzak - 177 pounds
- 1981 - Tom Martucci - 190 pounds
- 1981 - Tom Martucci - 190 pounds (Division I)
- 1982 - Steve Fernandez - 134 pounds
- 1982 - Bob Glaberman - 158 pounds
- 1984 - Bob Glaberman - 158 pounds
- 1985 - Tim Jacoutot - 118 pounds
- 1985 - Larry DeSimone - 150 pounds
- 1987 - Tim Jacoutot - 118 pounds
- 1987 - Greg MacDonald - 177 pounds
- 1987 - Vic Pozsonyi - 190 pounds
- 1988 - Tim Jacoutot - 118 pounds
- 1992 - Steve Rivera - 118 pounds
- 1993 - Glen Sandull - Heacyweight
- 1994 - Glen Sandull - Heavyweight
- 1996 - Chris Potter - 150 pounds
- 1999 - Justin Totten - 141 pounds
- 2003 - Dave Ilaria - 133 pounds
- 2012 - Mike Denver - 184 pounds
- 2019 - Ryan Budzek - 149 pounds
WOMEN'S TRACK AND FIELD
Indoor
- 2001 - Erica Distefano - High Jump
- 2005 - Brittny Boyd, Tiffany Clark, Carolyn Gray, Jessica Bonelli, and Angela Tecco - 4x400 relay
Outdoor
- 1981 - Jill Watts - Javelin
- 1982 - Colleen Casey - 5,000 meters
- 1982 - Jill Watts - Javelin
- 1984 - Margaret Brent, Helene Duffield, Sandy Humphrey, and Judy Hunt - 4x100 relay
- 1984 - Tonya Anderson, Sandy Humphrey, Judy Hunt, and Melissa Wenczel - 4x400 relay
- 1987 - Virginia Zalinski - 5,000 meters
- 1999 - Noel Whitall - 5,000 meters
- 2004 - Brittny Boyd, Kate Powell, Tiffany Clark, and Khristelle Manuyang - 4x100 relay
- 2004 - Brittny Boyd, Tiffany Clark, Kate Powell, and Angela Tecco - 4x400 relay
MEN'S TRACK AND FIELD
Indoor
- 2006 - Jeff Zodda - 800 meters
Outdoor
- 2003 - Nick Ricco - 5,000 meters
WOMEN'S TENNIS
- 1986 - Debbie Daniel
- 2007 - Jackie Shtemberg (ITA National Champion)