CANEEL BAY: 170 acre island with 7 distinct beaches, located in the Virgin Islands National Park. Lots of wildlife on property. Secluded - only able to arrive via ferry or private boat.
Includes: watersports (sailboats, kayaks, snorkeling gear), nightly movies, weekly cocktail reception, tennis courts. No TV or phones in rooms. Daily continental breakfast.
Spa on property with a variety of services - can request in room massage or massage on beach.
Every restaurant has a formal dress code.
Finished room pictures on their website: http://www.caneelbay.com/rooms-and-suites/default-en.html
THE BUCCANEER: 340 acres and 3 beaches on this hotel property on St. Croix. 18-hole golf course and several tennis courts on-property at an additional cost.
Includes: watersports (paddleboards, kayaks, snorkeling gear), nature and history walks, jogging trail, weekly cocktail reception, live entertainment on set days.
Current promotion: Every 4th night is free, daily buffet breakfast, $400 in USVI spending credits received when you arrive (coupons are in $25, $50, and $100 increments and are used towards a large variety of shopping, dining, and activities on the Virgin Islands).