TEFL Equity Advocates #TEA
What are NESTs & nNESTs ?
NEST - native English speaking teacher
i.e. somebody whose first language is English
NNEST - non-native English speaking teacher,
i.e. somebody whose first language isn’t English
These definitions have been criticised as inadequate. Peter Lahif in this post briefly explains why the term ‘native speaker’ is an unsound recruitment criteria:
Michael Griffin argues in his article that the terms NEST and NNEST only perpetuate stereotypes:
What are the main issues nNESTs face ?
Prejudice against them.
The myth of native speaker superiority.
Discriminatory hiring policies.
Lack of self-confidence.
A ‘look-the-other-way’ attitude from many teaching associations and ELT professionals.
Belief that things will never change.
It’s been the skeleton in the cupboard for way too long.
NESTs (in)directly benefit from the prejudice against NNESTs.
Turning down qualified, experienced and proficient teachers based only on their country of origin undermines professionalism, deprives students of some great teachers and has a negative effect on our profession as a whole.
But NEST is BEST, right ?
"The notion of a broader vocabulary range is a myth. Most NSs have no idea of how many words they know or use, and I don’t know of any tables comparing lexical range between sets of NSs or NNSs. A huge mythology is ‘out there." - David Crystal
NESTs are not necessarily good language models
NNESTs can also be good models of pronunciation
There’s no empirical corelation between being a good teacher and being a NEST.