Carolyn Renfrew (center) with Hastings Women’s Club after performance of My Garden, April 1938. Courtesy of Adams County Historical Society.
Carolyn Renfrew was born in Marseilles, Illinois, to Sylvester and Mercy Clark Renfrew. Sylvester was a farmer in Illinois and continued to farm after the family moved to Hastings in 1876. Six years later, Sylvester left farming to become a partner in Burger Brothers and Renfrew, a buggy and hardware business. By 1886, Sylvester was working as a farm proprietor, buying and selling land. Sylvester bought property that extended from 7th to 9th Street and from St Joseph to Hastings Ave. Sylvester’s successful business ventures comfortably supported his family after his death in 1888. Mercy and Sylvester had seven children: Alice Jo, Myra, Carolyn, Addie, Robert, Herman, and Jennie, who were educated in Hastings schools and with private tutors. The Renfrew family was cultured and well-educated as well as musically and literally inclined.
Carolyn began a singing career around 1895. Reviews have described her as a soprano with a high and pure voice. She toured the country as a singer, settling for a short time in Kansas City. However, after two years, Carolyn ended her concert tours citing frailty. She moved back to Hastings to live with her mother and siblings, Herman and Addie. In 1905, she moved to Colorado Springs with her sister Jennie. The two lived together until June 1910, when Mercy’s death called them back to Hastings. Jennie married Fay Babcock leaving Carolyn, Herman, and Addie to live in their family home. Carolyn, suffering from poor health herself, looked after Addie, who was chronically ill. The three siblings were notoriously private and preferred to keep visitors at the door. Carolyn restricted her social life to trips to the library and the occasional meeting of the Hastings Women’s Club.
Carolyn turned to writing as her next creative outlet. Though she never reached the success of Willa Cather, she was honored in several ways by her peers. She was invited to New York City to take part in the public poetry week and exhibit held by Rockefeller Center and Columbia University in 1936. However, ill health and the care of her sister kept her from attending. These reasons also prevented her from accepting a place on the Board of Directors for the 1939 World’s Fair in New York City, a position of Associate Editor of the Poetry Roundtable, and an invitation to the Leland Stanford University Drama Festival at Stanford University in California.